AWI Forecasts Greenland Glacier Ice Loss with Simulation

AWI Forecasts Greenland Glacier Ice Loss with Simulation

This sponsored report is brought to you by COMSOL.

To an individual standing near a glacier, it might appear to be as stable and long lasting as just about anything on Earth can be. Having said that, Earth’s excellent ice sheets are often transferring and evolving. In latest many years, this ceaseless motion has accelerated. In reality, ice in polar locations is proving to be not just cell, but alarmingly mortal.

Mounting air and sea temperatures are rushing up the discharge of glacial ice into the ocean, which contributes to world sea stage increase. This ominous progression is going on even more quickly than predicted. Existing designs of glacier dynamics and ice discharge underestimate the actual price of ice reduction in modern a long time. This would make the perform of Angelika Humbert, a physicist learning Greenland’s Nioghalvfjerdsbræ outlet glacier, especially crucial — and urgent.

As the chief of the Modeling Team in the Portion of Glaciology at the Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI) Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Investigate in Bremerhaven, Germany, Humbert operates to extract broader classes from Nioghalvfjerdsbræ’s ongoing decline. Her exploration combines info from subject observations with viscoelastic modeling of ice sheet conduct. By enhanced modeling of elastic effects on glacial stream, Humbert and her team search for to greater predict ice decline and the resulting impact on international sea levels.

She is acutely conscious that time is quick. “Nioghalvfjerdsbræ is 1 of the previous a few ‘floating tongue’ glaciers in Greenland,” points out Humbert. “Almost all of the other floating tongue formations have previously disintegrated.”

1 Glacier That Holds 1.1 Meter of Prospective International Sea Degree Increase

The North Atlantic island of Greenland is included with the world’s second major ice pack after that of Antarctica. (Fig. 1) Greenland’s sparsely populated landscape may well appear to be unspoiled, but local weather modify is basically tearing absent at its icy mantle.

The ongoing discharge of ice into the ocean is a “fundamental method in the ice sheet mass-stability,” according to a 2021 short article in Communications Earth & Natural environment by Humbert and her colleagues. (Ref. 1) The article notes that the complete Northeast Greenland Ice Stream has sufficient ice to increase worldwide sea concentrations by 1.1 meters. While the full formation is not anticipated to vanish, Greenland’s in general ice address has declined substantially due to the fact 1990. This course of action of decay has not been linear or uniform throughout the island. Nioghalvfjerdsbræ, for example, is now Greenland’s premier outlet glacier. The nearby Petermann Glacier applied to be much larger, but has been shrinking even extra speedily. (Ref. 2)

Present Products Underestimate the Rate of Ice Reduction

Greenland’s in general loss of ice mass is unique from “calving”, which is the breaking off of icebergs from glaciers’ floating tongues. Though calving does not directly elevate sea stages, the calving method can quicken the movement of land-based mostly ice towards the coast. Satellite imagery from the European Space Company (Fig. 2) has captured a quick and dramatic calving celebration in action. In between June 29 and July 24 of 2020, a 125 km2 floating part of Nioghalvfjerdsbræ calved into several separate icebergs, which then drifted off to soften into the North Atlantic.

Immediate observations of ice sheet habits are useful, but inadequate for predicting the trajectory of Greenland’s ice loss. Glaciologists have been setting up and refining ice sheet products for decades, nevertheless, as Humbert claims, “There is nonetheless a large amount of uncertainty about this strategy.” Commencing in 2014, the staff at AWI joined 14 other investigation teams to evaluate and refine their forecasts of potential ice decline via 2100. The undertaking also in contrast projections for previous decades to ice losses that really occurred. Ominously, the experts’ predictions had been “far beneath the really observed losses” given that 2015, as stated by Martin Rückamp of AWI. (Ref. 3) He states, “The types for Greenland underestimate the latest improvements in the ice sheet due to local climate adjust.”

Viscoelastic Modeling to Seize Rapidly-Performing Forces

Angelika Humbert has personally built several journeys to Greenland and Antarctica to get facts and investigate samples, but she recognizes the limits of the immediate solution to glaciology. “Field functions are extremely costly and time consuming, and there is only so significantly we can see,” she suggests. “What we want to discover is concealed within a procedure, and substantially of that process is buried beneath lots of tons of ice! We will need modeling to tell us what behaviors are driving ice decline, and also to exhibit us where to look for individuals behaviors.”

Due to the fact the 1980s, scientists have relied on numerical versions to explain and predict how ice sheets evolve. “They identified that you could seize the consequences of temperature modifications with versions designed all-around a viscous electrical power regulation functionality,” Humbert clarifies. “If you are modeling stable, extensive-expression behavior, and you get your viscous deformation and sliding ideal, your design can do a first rate job. But if you are making an attempt to capture loads that are switching on a limited time scale, then you need a unique solution.”

To superior realize the Northeast Greenland Ice Stream glacial method and its discharge of ice into the ocean, researchers at the Alfred Wegener Institute have produced an improved viscoelastic design to seize how tides and subglacial topography contribute to glacial circulation.

What drives small-term alterations in the loads that influence ice sheet actions? Humbert and the AWI workforce emphasis on two sources of these significant but improperly recognized forces: oceanic tidal motion under floating ice tongues (these kinds of as the a single shown in Fig. 2) and the ruggedly uneven landscape of Greenland alone. Both equally tidal motion and Greenland’s topography aid identify how speedily the island’s ice include is shifting toward the ocean.

To investigate the elastic deformation prompted by these elements, Humbert and her group built a viscoelastic model of Nioghalvfjerdsbræ in the COMSOL Multiphysics software program. The glacier model’s geometry is based on knowledge from radar surveys. The product solved fundamental equations for a viscoelastic Maxwell product across a 2D model domain consisting of a vertical cross area alongside the blue line demonstrated in Fig. 3. The simulated final results were then when compared to precise discipline measurements of glacier move acquired by four GPS stations, a person of which is demonstrated in Fig. 3.

How Cycling Tides Have an effect on Glacier Movement

The tides around Greenland ordinarily elevate and reduce the coastal h2o line involving 1 and 4 meters for every cycle. This motion exerts incredible power on outlet glaciers’ floating tongues, and these forces are transmitted into the land-based mostly sections of the glacier as very well. AWI’s viscoelastic design explores how these cyclical changes in tension distribution can affect the glacier’s move toward the sea.

The charts in Determine 4 current the calculated tide-induced stresses acting on Nioghalvfjerdsbræ at a few destinations, superimposed on stresses predicted by viscous and viscoelastic simulations. Chart a displays how displacements drop more when they are 14 kilometers inland from the grounding line (GL). Chart b displays that cyclical tidal stresses lessen at GPS-hinge, found in a bending zone close to the grounding line amongst land and sea. Chart c displays exercise at the locale identified as GPS-shelf, which is mounted on ice floating in the ocean. Accordingly, it shows the most pronounced waveform of cyclical tidal stresses acting on the ice.

“The floating tongue is moving up and down, which produces elastic responses in the land-dependent portion of the glacier,” states Julia Christmann, a mathematician on the AWI crew who plays a vital position in setting up their simulation designs. “There is also a subglacial hydrological procedure of liquid drinking water between the inland ice and the floor. This basal h2o system is improperly known, while we can see evidence of its consequences.” For illustration, chart a displays a spike in stresses beneath a lake sitting down atop the glacier. “Lake h2o flows down by means of the ice, the place it adds to the subglacial drinking water layer and compounds its lubricating result,” Christmann says.

The plotted pattern traces highlight the higher precision of the team’s new viscoelastic simulations, as in contrast to purely viscous types. As Christmann points out, “The viscous product does not capture the comprehensive extent of adjustments in anxiety, and it does not clearly show the suitable amplitude. (See chart c in Fig. 4.) In the bending zone, we can see a stage shift in these forces due to elastic reaction.” Christmann continues, “You can only get an accurate product if you account for viscoelastic ‘spring’ action.”

Modeling Elastic Strains from Uneven Landscapes

The crevasses in Greenland’s glaciers expose the unevenness of the underlying landscape. Crevasses also supply further evidence that glacial ice is not a purely viscous material. “You can view a glacier above time and see that it creeps, as a viscous material would,” states Humbert. Nonetheless, a purely viscous substance would not variety persistent cracks the way that ice sheets do. “From the commencing of glaciology, we have experienced to take the reality of these crevasses,” she claims. The team’s viscoelastic design provides a novel way to explore how the land beneath Nioghalvfjerdsbræ facilitates the emergence of crevasses and has an effect on glacial sliding.

Aerial view of Nioghalvfjerdsbr\u00e6 glacier showing vast expanse of ice covered by deep crevasses.

Figure 5. Aerial see of Nioghalvfjerdsbræ demonstrating the substantial patterns of the crevasses.

Julia Christmann/Alfred Wegener Institute

“When we did our simulations, we have been astonished at the volume of elastic strain created by topography,” Christmann points out. “We observed these consequences much inland, where by they would have almost nothing to do with tidal adjustments.”

Determine 6 displays how vertical deformation in the glacier corresponds to the underlying landscape and can help scientists fully grasp how localized elastic vertical movement impacts the total sheet’s horizontal movement. Shaded parts point out velocity in that portion of the glacier when compared to its basal velocity. Blue zones are moving vertically at a slower price than the sections that are right previously mentioned the floor, indicating that the ice is currently being compressed. Pink and purple zones are moving speedier than ice at the base, demonstrating that ice is remaining vertically stretched.

These simulation results recommend that the AWI team’s improved model could give additional precise forecasts of glacial actions. “This was a ‘wow’ outcome for us,” says Humbert. “Just as the up and down of the tides results in elastic strain that has an effect on glacier flow, now we can capture the elastic portion of the up and down more than bedrock as properly.”

Scaling Up as the Clock Runs Down

The improved viscoelastic design of Nioghalvfjerdsbræ is only the latest example of Humbert’s a long time-extensive use of numerical simulation instruments for glaciological exploration. “COMSOL is quite very well suited to our operate,” she claims. “It is a superb resource for making an attempt out new thoughts. The software program would make it relatively effortless to change options and perform new simulation experiments with no acquiring to generate customized code.” Humbert’s university students frequently integrate simulation into their exploration. Illustrations contain Julia Christmann’s PhD operate on the calving of ice shelves, and another diploma venture that modeled the evolution of the subglacial channels that carry meltwater from the surface area to the ice base.

The AWI group is happy of their investigative operate, but they are fully cognizant of just how substantially information about the world’s ice address stays mysterious — and that time is limited. “We are unable to afford to pay for Maxwell content simulations of all of Greenland,” Humbert concedes. “We could burn up several years of computational time and still not protect everything. But most likely we can parameterize the localized elastic reaction outcomes of our product, and then employ it at a larger scale,” she claims.

This scale defines the challenges faced by 21st-century glaciologists. The measurement of their investigation topics is staggering, and so is the worldwide significance of their function. Even as their expertise is growing, it is imperative that they come across far more details, extra promptly. Angelika Humbert would welcome input from men and women in other fields who study viscoelastic supplies. “If other COMSOL customers are dealing with fractures in Maxwell resources, they likely face some of the very same issues that we have, even if their versions have nothing at all to do with ice!” she states. “Maybe we can have an trade and deal with these troubles alongside one another.”

Perhaps, in this spirit, we who advantage from the get the job done of glaciologists can assist shoulder some of the vast and weighty issues they bear.


  1. J. Christmann, V. Helm, S.A. Khan, A. Humbert, et al. “Elastic Deformation Performs a Non-Negligible Position in Greenland’s Outlet Glacier Stream“, Communications Earth & Environment, vol. 2, no. 232, 2021.
  2. European Place Company, “Spalte Breaks Up“, September 2020.
  3. Alfred Wegener Institute, Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research, “Model comparison: Specialists calculate long term ice decline and the extent to which Greenland and the Antarctic will lead to sea-stage increase“, September 2020.